Freebie is over

Claims for the recovery of unjust enrichment for the use of a land plot of 570,510 sq. m. have been sent to LLC "Kirovsky Biokhimzavod" (KIBIKH), LLC "GrandLesProm", and other companies at 53A Luganska St.

Following the publication of the article "A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing" and additional inquiries to the Ministry of Economic Development, Alexey Egorov received a response, the text of which he cites in his latest open letter, which, at his request, is traditionally published by the editorial board of "Business News".

"The owners of all 47 real estate properties have been identified. Let us hope that they will also become known to the Federal Tax Service (FTS) for the Kirov Region, and the budget of the Kirov Region will be replenished with property taxes from these objects.

In its letter, the Ministry of Economic Development reports that back in 2012, a number of companies were sued for debt incurred for the actual use of the land plot.

And in 2016, LLC "Vostokenergo", LLC "GrandLesProm", and LLC "KIBIKH" were found liable for debt for the actual use of the entire area of the Land Plot.

Moreover, the Interregional Territorial Administration of Rosimushchestvo (Federal Agency for State Property Management) in the Udmurt Republic and Kirov Region has sent claims to the right holders of the real estate properties for the recovery of unjust enrichment for the use of the Land Plot.

However, questions arise, which have been sent to the Prosecutor's Office, and we expect to receive answers soon:

By what miraculous means could the owners of the real estate properties use the land for so long without Rosimushchestvo or its Territorial Administration reacting to this fact? You must agree, recognizing a debt in 2016 and taking no action to recover it can hardly be called active measures.

If we accept as fact that the debt in 2016 was formed for the period from 2012 to 2016, then, considering the general statute of limitations, it can be argued that the debt amounts accrued for the period from 2012 to 2015 will not be recovered from the debtors. The question is, who is to blame for this? And the extent of the damage caused to the budget of the Russian Federation remains outside the scope of the Ministry of Economic Development's response. I hope the Prosecutor's Office staff will find the answer to this question.

If, as follows from the Ministry's letter, property rights to all 47 objects (we remind you that the publication reported only about 25 objects visible in the extract from the state register) were lawfully formalized, why are these rights not properly registered in the state register? By what miracle could the persons mentioned in the Ministry's response confirm their rights to the real estate objects if they had not formalized land use rights for the plots under these objects?

As we can see, there are many questions, and a certain residue remains that a number of entrepreneurs in the Kirov Region are actively operating in violation of the laws, while state bodies do not respond and suppress such violations in a timely manner!

As a result, we cannot build new schools, equip hospitals, kindergartens… A selective approach of "us vs. them" does not contribute to business development in the Kirov Region, and impunity generates new violations and disregard for the law."